Former Federal Public Defender Sues the Federal Judiciary; Supreme Court Opts to Shield their Own from Accountability

Monday, November 16, 2026

For Immediate Release

Contact: Aliza Shatzman, 267-481-2095, aliza.shatzman@legalaccountabilityproject.org

Former Federal Public Defender Sues the Federal Judiciary; Supreme Court Opts to Shield their Own from Accountability

The federal judiciary is perpetrating a fraud upon the public, exploiting judicial law clerks’ and other judiciary employees’ fear and silence. The judiciary knows employees won’t file complaints, let alone sue, as long as they are not legally protected against retaliation under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. 

The Legal Accountability Project (LAP) has stood shoulder to shoulder with former federal public defender Caryn Strickland over the past several years, applauding her bravery and dogged persistence at a time when courage is in short supply. LAP most recently assisted Strickland in taking her case up to the Supreme Court and also filed an amicus brief in collaboration with the Georgia Association of Women Lawyers (GAWL). While today’s denial of Strickland’s cert petition is not the outcome we hoped for, this is a landmark case despite the outcome. Strickland’s case raises a fundamental question, and it’s disappointing yet not surprising the Supreme Court refused to engage with it: is it constitutional for one-third of our federal government–the judiciary–and its more than 30,000 employees to go to work every day in a workplace that falls far short of the standards prescribed by Title VII of the Civil Rights Act? LAP would argue, it is not.

Judicial branch employees, as Strickland quickly learned while pursuing an internal workplace complaint in her North Carolina Federal Defender Office, lack an impartial and transparent forum to resolve workplace disputes. Yet judiciary employees, who support the daily functioning of our courts while lacking rights and protections themselves, deserve the same neutral forum to sue as the litigants who appear before them every day in the courts. 

Laws are a deterrent: we shouldn’t be surprised that in a workplace exempt from all federal anti-discrimination, labor, civil rights, and whistleblower laws, judges and federal defenders regularly harass, discriminate against, and retaliate against employees with impunity. Strickland’s case is just the latest in a long line of examples–including, most recently, Georgia federal judge Eleanor Ross, who had sex in her chambers with a law enforcement officer in earshot of clerks and lied to the court about it; and Texas federal judge Ada Brown, who abandoned her job as a federal judge and refused to participate in a misconduct investigation–that underscore the urgent necessity of congressional action. This is, in fact, Congress’s constitutionally-mandated obligation.

Both chambers of Congress will switch over to Democratic hands come January. Incoming House Judiciary Chairman Jamie Raskin, and incoming Senate Judiciary Chairman Sheldon Whitehouse, must immediately reintroduce and pass the Judiciary Accountability Act (JAA). This is a theoretically bipartisan bill, given that the last two judges whose misconduct made news were appointed by presidents of two different political parties. The JAA would finally extend Title VII to more than 30,000 vulnerable judiciary employees, and would have provided employees like Strickland with a fair and neutral forum to sue and seek redress, particularly financial redress, for harms done to their lives, careers, and reputations. Congress must also hold hearings with both experts and judicial branch officials; subpoena documents, records, and testimony; and use its appropriations power to cut the judiciary’s budget until it implements reforms or tie its annual budgetary request to meaningful benchmarks for reform. 

While there is bipartisan public support for correcting the injustices highlighted in Strickland’s case, it’s disheartening that there has historically been bipartisan unwillingness on Capitol Hill to address this problem. LAP urges Congress to act swiftly in early 2027 to finally hold judges accountable for misconduct, and to hold the judiciary to the same standards as other workplaces, including federal workplaces. It’s antithetical to the fair and impartial administration of justice, that judges who interpret our laws are exempt from those same laws; and that judiciary employees, including public defenders like Strickland, who work tirelessly to ensure others’ rights are protected, lack basic rights and protections themselves. 

Next
Next

Harvard, Georgetown, and NYU Lead The Legal Accountability Project’s Clerkships Database Subscribers By Law School for 2025–26